This sounds like the classic nuts & bolts vs WTF theories that have been kicked back and forth for years. On one side - demonstrated right here at AE at times - you have those that see physics and math as a hobby and they attempt to parse what data is available to support theories amenable to that. Understandable, its a traditional approach and not a bad one. However I've seen derision heaped on those who suggest that the answer is far more convoluted than that as those theories do not fit into traditional lines of thinking. No reason both couldn't exist side by side but ego and emotion often interfere.
There are similarities seen in NDE and after death communication; the brain as the source of consciousness is the traditional model, at least from the 20th century forward. Again, those who suggest alternate theories like brain as a receiver are often subject to ridicule. Not unusual when contemporary thought encounters something new and by comparison radical.
Personally, I see both as the latter that's not something that can be easily quantified and filed away. Current thinking is that it all relates to consciousness and I don't consider that woo woo just because its not easily understood much less quantifiable. IMO the two phenomenon are related by this.
Here's my often misinterpreted caution; both of these fields are subject to perfectly human foibles like the need for attention, control of a narrative, greed, you name it. Whatever is real is inevitably mixed in with pure horseshit designed to attract a certain following or achieve a certain goal. This is where I file away military deception, maskirovka, as its always been a useful tool for the military and when I talk about reconnaissance devices undoubtedly at least some of that is what's being reported.
I really have no clue how it would be possible at this point to separate the wheat from the chaff but do think that mixed in all that there are entirely real events, incidents, what have you. The BS obscures whatever is real.
Two old school men who have said as much are Jacques Vallee and John B Alexander and at this point they are probably tired of saying it as it never seemes to gain any traction.
Good points and I mostly agree with them.
This phenomenon though is definitely more complex than what most of us imagine, let alone the very likely situation that what modern science actually reached today in terms of evolvement is not know by most of the population, as there's clearly an almost century old gap between civilian science and military-industrial complex science.
And, to worsen it all, modern people has been led to think the extraordinary anomalous events observed are either paranormal phenomena caused by "entities from other dimensions" or just holographic or materialised manifestations of a higher consciousness.
Of course, those are obviously occurrences that hark back to the origins of life in this universe, but they are also an obvious distraction from a much more directly influential aspect of the UFO phenomenon to our earthly reality, an aspect which involves the same physics, the same chemistry, the same biology in our entire universe. In fact, what's loosely referred to as "nuts and bolts" of the UFO phenomenon is definitely a much more present aspect that probably has long impacted our lives and might impact us even more, let alone the historical UFO abduction issue.
Now, given this long narrative focused on derailing us from the knowing the actual facts, let alone the real history of our species on this planet, it's gotten too hard to separate the wheat from the chaff.
One example is most of today's politicians, who are geniuses when it comes to take profit of the chaos in a society in the most imaginable opportunistic way to spread even more misinformation.
In my country the most recently prominent example is Aldo Rebello, here in Brasil nobody from the news has EVER mentioned that Aldo Rebello (Minister of Defense from Oct. 2015 to May 2016) admitted the Varginha UFO case was true. Curiously enough, this should be in the news everywhere, how come such indifference? I've been following the news regarding the UFO Varginha case to a reasonable extent, and I'm just being aware of that Rebello's statement during David Grush's press conference in the Capitolium.
Sure enough though, the Brasilian people have been living in a BUBBLE like never seen in the history of this country. But then night this reality extend to most of the world population?
Spielberg's CEoTK's was a worldwide fever in the seventies, now what? I think this contrast reflect big changes our societies have gone through in half a century. For good or for bad? Well, to each their own...
Brazil's former Defense Minister and current presidential candidate Aldo Rebelo confirms the country has had contact with non-human intelligence dating back to at least the 70’s. He says that in 1977, in Colares, UFOs were injuring civilians in the Amazon with burns, puncture wounds and blood loss serious enough to trigger a classified military investigation. In 1986, six fighter jets were scrambled against 21 unidentified craft detected by radar – the objects were flying at Mach 20+ and making right angle turns, maneuvers well beyond the capabilities of the most advanced craft today. He also confirms that the 1996 Varginha UFO crash occurred, that non-human beings were encountered, and says he fully believes the neurosurgeon who came face to face with one of them in a hospital bed. He also confirms the American military would have had an immediate strategic interest in the case. Rebelo says there is more classified information about these cases and others, and that they should be released alongside America's. Rebelo’s confirmation of the events at Varginha is the equivalent of former Defense Ministers in the United States like Robert Baker or Jim Mattis saying Roswell happened; its world history that can’t be walked back. And it ends decades of condescension and gaslighting from top ranking officials on this topic.
SPOILER ALERT:
Aldo Rebello has also stated he'll open up the whole truth about the "ET de Varginha" case if he wins the presidential race.
Don't expect him to that.