Three-month investigation proves "Trinity" 1945 UFO-crash story is a hoax

Dean

Adept Dabbler
THE TRINITY 1945 UFO-CRASH HOAX

In January 2023, Jacques Vallee told the New York Times, the UK Daily Mail, and other news media that in August 1945, three witnesses--two boys and a military pilot overhead--simultaneously saw a crashed UFO in New Mexico. I spent three months digging into those claims, and I have now published my findings in a suite of 14 articles. The gateway article, which includes an index and a summary of each of the topical sub-articles, is found at the link below.


However, for those who would rather read one short illustrative narrative (rather than a long summary of my wide-ranging inquiries, findings, and conclusions), I recommend my little article about New Mexico State Police Officer Eddie Apodaca. In the Trinity UFO-crash tale told by Jacques Vallee and Paola Harris in their book Trinity: The Best-Kept Secret, Eddie Apodaca is a key figure -- a "friend of the family" who actually entered the crashed alien craft on August 18, 1945. However, my investigation documented that Officer Apodaca, although he really existed, had been hijacked and inserted into the hoaxers' work of fiction. The real Eddie Apodaca was with the Army Air Corps in Germany in August 1945, and did not return to New Mexico until at least three months after the fictional UFO crash. Moreover, Apodaca was not commissioned as a police officer until August, 1951-- six years after the fictional UFO crash. After that, the real Officer Apodaca became a well-known figure in Socorro County, where the two future hoaxers, Reme Baca and Jose Padilla, were living in their early teens. For details and contemporary documents, see the article at the link below.


Douglas Dean Johnson

@ddeanjohnson on Twitter
 

Dean

Adept Dabbler
Hi Dean,

I saw your link posted elsewhere, and went and read all the articles. Excellent work! I had no doubt that the story was pure fiction, but holy cow, what a mess! I'm not surprised that Harris was taken in by such sloppy grifters, but I'm still having trouble wrapping my head around Vallee falling for it. He really stepped in it this time. The more you look, the dumber it gets.
 

Creepy Green Light

Don't mistake lack of talent for genius
THE TRINITY 1945 UFO-CRASH HOAX

In January 2023, Jacques Vallee told the New York Times, the UK Daily Mail, and other news media that in August 1945, three witnesses--two boys and a military pilot overhead--simultaneously saw a crashed UFO in New Mexico. I spent three months digging into those claims, and I have now published my findings in a suite of 14 articles. The gateway article, which includes an index and a summary of each of the topical sub-articles, is found at the link below.


However, for those who would rather read one short illustrative narrative (rather than a long summary of my wide-ranging inquiries, findings, and conclusions), I recommend my little article about New Mexico State Police Officer Eddie Apodaca. In the Trinity UFO-crash tale told by Jacques Vallee and Paola Harris in their book Trinity: The Best-Kept Secret, Eddie Apodaca is a key figure -- a "friend of the family" who actually entered the crashed alien craft on August 18, 1945. However, my investigation documented that Officer Apodaca, although he really existed, had been hijacked and inserted into the hoaxers' work of fiction. The real Eddie Apodaca was with the Army Air Corps in Germany in August 1945, and did not return to New Mexico until at least three months after the fictional UFO crash. Moreover, Apodaca was not commissioned as a police officer until August, 1951-- six years after the fictional UFO crash. After that, the real Officer Apodaca became a well-known figure in Socorro County, where the two future hoaxers, Reme Baca and Jose Padilla, were living in their early teens. For details and contemporary documents, see the article at the link below.


Douglas Dean Johnson

@ddeanjohnson on Twitter
Great work. Although I do find it hard to believe that someone would make up a story about seeing a flying saucer (flying, landed or crashed) just to sell a book. Just kidding.
 

Dean

Adept Dabbler
Great work. Although I do find it hard to believe that someone would make up a story about seeing a flying saucer (flying, landed or crashed) just to sell a book. Just kidding.
There is good evidence that the hoaxers in this case had hopes for a big payday, way beyond book sales, as I wrote up in another article linked below. (I have written 10 main articles on this hoax, plus four sidebars, all published May 1, 2023.) But I did not find evidence that their various efforts to cash in were terribly successful.

 
Dean, do you feel there is ultimately anything to the phenomenon at all? Just the number of hoaxes and grifters boggles the mind... There is so much damn noise on this field.
 
Last edited:
Had to ask, since it seems sometimes some researchers get enough of the insane signal/noise ratio here, and basically turn to debunkers who now lean heavily on the psycho social explanations, like V. J. Ballester-Olmos, who was one of the researchers involved in one of the best books on this. Now a heavy promoter of "youre wasting your time, there is nothing to it at all".

314aFJDDDNL._SX218_BO1,204,203,200_QL40_FMwebp_.jpg
 
Last edited:

pigfarmer

tall, thin, irritable
At $20 for Kindle and $40 or so for used paperbacks I am willing to let their opinions sit on the shelf a while longer.

There is absolutely a sociological component to this phenomenon - but as many have said there's no panacea, no one size fits all answer.
 

Todd Feinman

Show us the satellite pics...
Honestly,
I don't pay attention anymore to UFO crash retrieval stories --they aren't necessary to establish the reality of the phenomenon, and it seems almost all of them are hoaxes.
I never got around to reading Vallee's book...
 

pigfarmer

tall, thin, irritable
I read the most recent three articles Dean wrote. Vallee might not care for what's being said but it was certainly polite. Apparently Dean's work touched a soft spot.
 

Creepy Green Light

Don't mistake lack of talent for genius
Honestly,
I don't pay attention anymore to UFO crash retrieval stories --they aren't necessary to establish the reality of the phenomenon, and it seems almost all of them are hoaxes.
I never got around to reading Vallee's book...
As far as I know the only crash retrieval that was real was Kecksburg, PA (unfortunately wasn't a flying saucer though).
 
Top