Kchoo
At Peace.
** COOL NERD FODDER ALERT! **
Today we realize that the entire solar system is encased inside an embryo of the Sun called the Heliosphere, outside of which anything else is lost in space, so it's hard to envision any object the size of a large planetary body is hiding inside the Suns Heliosphere but still making regular orbits every 5,000 years. It's not logical when you place the idea in the context of what we know about our place in space and the Milky Way Galaxy we live in. It takes Earth about 260 million years to make one galactic orbit. Planet X would have to be inside the Sun's Helioshpere in order to be orbiting, and if it's outside of the Heliosphere it cannot be worth considering as a regular visitor, but rather a freak passing recorded somewhere in the past, which was probably not a planetary body, just seemed like it was.
Heliosphere - Wikipedia
The combined speed of our star and our solar system exceeds a half million miles per hour when all the angular trajectories are accounted for, which is about six of them all told. So many factors are against the idea of hidden planet that another explanation is needed if the idea is be given any credence at all.
What is the Speed of the Earth?